Looking at the parallels between the development of the telegraph and the development of the internet made it very clear that: no matter what the specific technology is, some things will always happen as a result of a new technology being introduced into a society. This is true because human nature will remain more or less constant, and so we (as a society) will react similarly to whatever new technology comes next. New technologies will go through 4 phases:
0-invented but not used (this makes me think of the Google self-driving cars!)
1-gimmick; new flashy toy that only a few own
2-used for things we can already do
3-technology used in new ways to solve problems
It is important to remember that technology has consequences in all facets of our world. As we developed the generalizations together in class last week, specific examples kept popping into my head and I wanted to outline some of those here:
Technology can make some things easier/better while simultaneously making other things harder/creating challenges:
>>interactive lesson programs like Classflow or Nearpod make interactive lessons easier but create a bandwith issue for the school/IT department to deal with
There will always be people who use technology for good and others who use technology for harm or self-interest:
>>this makes me think about the Common Sense Media conversations we have to consistently have with our students to make sure they are safe online
Technology speeds up the spread of information AND misinformation--we must teach others to judge information:
>>just last week we were dealing with rumors of "clown threats" and within 24 hours, my entire class of 4th graders knew of this rumor, without having any idea where the information came from
Technology costs money!
>>some of my students who do not have access to technology regularly at home will not be able to complete certain assignments at home
With the complete overload of information in our society today and the abundance of technologies available to us, it is absolutely crucial for us be informed and aware so that we can make the best choices for our students AND teach them to make appropriate choices in the technology-filled world they live in!
Christine...we sure face similar challenges with our fourth graders. I had the same clown problem. It always amazes me that students won't know what their parents do for a living but they know all about clowns and Clinton and Trump shenanigans. I do think the point you made about always circling back to make sure our students are using the internet safely is absolutely correct. I am going to have to remind myself to remain vigilant. They are young and do forget safety measures and also have a lot of curiosity! What do you do about the kids who do not have technology at home? Do you create an alternative assignment or have them complete it in class....just wondering.
ReplyDeleteThis time I let him complete it in class but you're right, depending on the assignment, an alternative may be in order.
DeleteChristine,
ReplyDeleteLike Jen, my fourth graders are very similar to yours. We also had the same clown issue in my room. Unfortunately, it happened when I wasn't there and resulted in a lot of tears. I am in complete agreement with you, for all the good that technology does; it can lead an awful lot of misinformation. Online safety is so important for our young students, who often forget how to act appropriately, and remain safe online. How do you teach this to your students?
Your last paragraph made me think of class this past week and talking about affordances. It's crazy, how many different programs are out there "designed" to help students learn. Just this week, I received four different emails about products being the next great thing to help students learn.
We use the common sense media lessons on digital citizenship to set a foundation and then I reinforce as it comes up with situations throughout the year.
DeleteOh, the clowns! Talk about relevant to our discuss about technology being used for harm. This issue really does highlight how fast information can spread, and just like a game of telephone, how quickly misinformation spreads. We often think adults are the only ones who fall for falsehoods on the internet because they "didn't grow up with it," but kids are just as susceptible. I think it's so important to teach our students how to think critically about what they see on the internet because it affects how these students live whether it's about a fade, or the world news.
ReplyDeleteLast year I made this great lesson using Nearpod and when I went to have my kids do it, their devices were unresponsive, didn't work, or didn't connect at all - talk about the bandwidth issues! It resulted in a completely wasted lesson, the kids utterly frustrated, and some in tears.
ReplyDeleteI get the crazy amount of emails about new products, too. Unfortunately, it is so hard to figure out the affordances offered by these new products without being able to try them out.