With SO many technology options at our fingertips today, affordance analysis is a crucial component of designing learning experiences. If we are just trying to tack on any technology to say that we included technology in our lessons, then we are totally missing the mark. Looking at what is required in a lesson (learning goals) and what possibilities lie before us--where they intersect is called an affordance. Although it may be helpful to consider how easy it is to use a certain technology, that is not the key point. What really matters is HOW can you use it? Does the technology offer you the appropriate possibilities for what you are trying to accomplish? What kinds of restraints does it have? If it has too many constraints, it may not be the best tool to select for that learning experience.
Last week, while we looked at two technologies to determine possibilities and constraints, it was crystal clear. A technology might be "cool" or exciting, but it may have very limited applications in your classroom. The ozobots we looked at were exciting at first glance, but once we looked at them a little more, it was very easy to see that they were difficult to use (usability) and were also going to be difficult to relate to our curriculum (utility)--never mind the price tag! All of these things combined, made it easy to see that this technology was not one worth investing in for my classroom or school. They may be more appropriate in another setting (like high school or STEM camp), but not for me!
If we want to incorporate technology wisely and appropriately into our classrooms, we MUST stop and think about affordance. First, what do I need to accomplish? Then, what tool can help me accomplish these goals?
I don't know about you, but I feel like I've been doing things backwards for so long. Finding a "cool" technology and figuring out how to make it fit with my curriculum. While this can work some of the time, to use what we already have access to, we definitely need to focus more on going from learning goals to appropriate technology. We can use all the "cool" tools we come across in a toolbox to choose the appropriate one from.
ReplyDeleteChristine, I totally agree with you about the ozobots. They are very cool to play with and I know we should encourage some play, but even us adults got off task and started playing with them without trying to figure out the educational application. I can't imagine my 9 year olds with them? Now....if we had more time and the pacing guidelines weren't so tight, then maybe we could more easily incorporate it.
ReplyDeleteYou are so right. I can’t believe I never thought about it before. Technologies that always just seemed cool, were okay with me to try out. Only after trying them, I realized that they really didn’t serve the purpose that I wanted them too. Paying attention to how the technologies meet the learning goals and avoid the constraints, will save so much time, frustration, and money on unnecessary technologies. I also completely agree the Ozobot was very cool and fun to play with, however, I don’t see them useful in my classroom.
ReplyDeleteYou summed it up perfectly. We can't just add in the technology--we really need to think about HOW to use it. We must look at the affordance and ask questions about usability and utility. If the answers continue to be no, we need to rethink implementing the technology.
ReplyDelete