Tuesday, November 15, 2016

Copyright Clarity

So I realize that the whole point of this book was to make copyright issues more clear for us...but I still feel a little confused after this all. First, I have to totally shift my mind from everything that has been ingrained in me for so many years. Second, I have to get over the fact that so many people I've trusted, have somewhat misled me (I'm partly joking...). But third, and most importantly, I have to sift through all of the aspects of fair use. I have to consider purpose, nature, amount used, and the market impact. The tricky part is that ALL of these factors must be considered. So, if I'm not taking away money from someone but I didn't change the work or change its purpose, then it's not fair use. Or, if I use more than is "acceptable," then it's not fair use--keep in mind, there are no hard and fast rules for how much is "OK." All of this is to say, I understand why some teachers take the whatever approach and ignore any rules or guidelines because they feel overwhelmed....and why others get overwhelmed and decide to just avoid it altogether. Bottom line, people find copyright issues overwhelming. Part of this fear has been brought on by bigger companies or corporations trying to instill fear in people by using intimidation to get people to avoid using their materials. Many times, those individuals may have been operating under Fair Use but did not realize it OR did not feel like they could put up a fight against the big dogs. When we understand the premise of copyright and fair use, then we will have equipped ourselves well to consume and produce information more freely. We must use these parameters to help us navigate the information world we live in. Otherwise, we are doing our students a huge disservice. If we avoid the issue, our students will never be responsible users and producers of information.

3 comments:

  1. I agree with you—fair use and copyright are very confusing topics. We have been falsely ingrained and misguided about them for years. It’s probably going to take years to break. I’m STILL confused about certain aspects—there’s a lot of gray area there! Even doing my Pecha Kucha, I was second-guessing myself and feeling a little frustrated. When we’re worried about getting into trouble, we want a yes or a no; not a “well, maybe?” However, I felt better after learning about transformativeness and how we can transform works for educational purposes...I think…JK…maybe… ;).

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with you and Beth. Copyright is so confusing. After reading the book, I feel as though I have a better understanding of it, but it also left me with more questions as well. I think that may have been the point. As teachers, I think we are so used to having guidelines that we can follow to tell us what to do or what not to do, and unfortunately, we don't get that with copyright and fair use.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Christine....you are so funny. I felt a little confused as well, but after presenting our projects and listening to Dawn's comments I feel like I have a pretty good grasp on clip art. Now, music???? Not so sure.....

    ReplyDelete