Tuesday, September 27, 2016

Situated Cognition and the Culture of Learning

Students must become apprentices, cognitive apprentices--they must learn how to think! They must learn to solve real world, authentic problems with the teacher alongside them as the "sage on the side" as Dr. Norton put it. We must be the experts but we must help students learn by creating/designing authentic learning experiences. There must be collaboration and reflection for learning to be long-lasting. We must situate them with tools in a given context--that is to say we give them a real problem that is relevant to them (context), give them the activity to be done in this context, and then give them the tools they need to accomplish this. Remember, a concept can be a tool just as much as a physical tool is a tool! I never really thought of a concept in that way but it makes sense now that it has been said. Oftentimes I think we get so caught up in the new "tools" or technologies or whatever is "in" at the time that we design an activity based on the tool. It's an easy trap to fall into, one that I am guilty of for sure. What we really should be doing is starting with the problem and what we want our students to learn. THEN, we can decide which tool or tools fit in with that skill or lesson. Having clear outlines of ABCs, AeCTS, and SPDs makes this process much more obvious and attainable I think.

I sat in a professional development meeting today about Project Based Learning (PBL). We looked at and discussed the difference principles of PBL and several resonated with me as things we have been highlighting in class as important: authenticity, challenging problem, reflection, collaboration, critique, and revision. Wow! It fits right in! We looked at an example of a project and were asked to identify which elements of PBL were present--I found myself being much more critical than my peers as a result of what I've learned in our class! I was quickly able to recognize things that were designed well for the problem and the activity vs things that were just "fun" but may not have actually served a purpose. It reminded me a lot of the conversations we've had about planning vs designing. Two things resonated with me--PBL is being taken on as an initiative and we are "required" to plan two PBL lessons for this school year. PBL should not be an isolated thing that we do because we have to meet a requirement! It should be the way in which we approach learning in general! Secondly, it was clear to see that we, as teachers, are not taught to look at teaching/education through this lens and that there is a lot of work to be done on the back end of educating our teachers. It is frustrating that our teacher prep programs did not equip us well for this type of long-lasting learning. It is my hope that I can bring a lot of this to my team and school, especially as it all becomes more fluid and natural to me in my own classroom.

5 comments:

  1. And now you have tools (conceptual ones - ABCS and SPD and AeCTS - to make project-based learning a reality. It is one thing to state it as a mandate or goal; it is another to make it real and not just another "fun thing." And, you can share those tools through talking and modeling the ways they inform practice!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Christine,
    You are 100% right. I've been sitting in CLT's and PD's about PBL's and finding places to implement them. Part of is just seems so fake. As if we are just doing it for the sake of being able to say that it was done. One of my team partners and I were talking the other day about trying to figure out how to make PBL a more prominent part of our teaching. I've already started discussing with her the conceptual tools that we have been learning in class, and she is willing to take the journey with to make our student's education more authentic for them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yes!! I was nodding with every sentence of your post! Now that we're learning about designing these kinds of authentic lessons, I see how they can shape a unit/lesson towards the ideas project-based learning wants us to implement (pretty much PICKLE). Before this class, I always thought of project-based learning as something in addition to what we were already doing. I bet many teachers still feel this way...they leave a professional development going, "And now they want us to do this on top of what we are already doing?! I can't catch a break!" But as you said in your post, these are not separate entities. The flood gates of creativity open when a teacher realizes that the concepts PBL wants us to incorporate into lessons are concepts that can be (and should be) embedded into a lesson already. The lessons become much more meaningful to all when this realization occurs. It's baby steps for sure, but it can be done.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Christine, I too am getting ready to attend three OTTW meetings at the county with my principal and TRT. I feel like this class is helping me feel a little above the learning curve. Most of our staff is on board but need a little encouraging. The two required projects mandated by the county is funny to me too. I guess administration has to have some kind of guidelines to push the leery beyond their comfort zone. I feel like each year, staff will increase the number of projects they do. As our TRT has pointed out OTTW really don't have to be weeks long projects. It's just a different way of designing lessons with an end game in mind. So happy for you that you felt confident in the professional development day. That is a nice feeling!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I absolutely agree! Last year with OttW being new, and I was also on the Loudoun Creates initiative, I feel like OttW was drilled over and over and over but wasn't approached in this clear way. I was getting really irritated with hearing about OttW without more guidance. Now I have the tools to help myself and my team to make OttW lessons that follow our design principles and will definitely result in more meaningful student learning. I don't know about you, but our OttW lessons last year were kind of a stretch. Now that I know more about situating the activity in the culture, our lessons were 100% in the culture of school and nowhere else.

    ReplyDelete